Good, But Somewhat Disappointing (Eleanor, WV United States) May 7, 2002 -... Money-Employment-Careers Best Sellers
Books, eBooks & Other Information Products
Money-Employment.Marc8.com 
Tue December 2, 2008
Money-Employment Home     Books     eBooks
Book - Customer Review:40

Come Into My Trading Room: A Complete Guide to Trading
Alexander Elder, Alexander Elder

Come Into My Trading Room: A Complete Guide to Trading - image
Rating: 4.5/5 Stars
Rank: 1252
Good, But Somewhat Disappointing
(Eleanor, WV United States) May 7, 2002 - 3.0/5 stars

Dr. Elders first book, "Trading for a Living" made a significant impact one me. I must have 10 "throw away" trading books for each of the 10-12 key books that have had most influence on me and that I keep close.

Trading for a Living is one of those books I keep close. So, it was with great expectation that I dove into my early release copy.

I must say that I came away somewhat disappointed.

A lot of the material in this book was presented in Trading for a Living.

Price-MACD histogram divergences are still one of the strongest signals. The triple screen trading method was discussed (but now uses a moving average instead of weekly-histogram.) Force Index is still used to define entry points.

So, there was a lot of ground covered that appeared in Trading for a Living.

Having said that, I must also say that some new things are introduced. The Chandelier method of stops has already replaced my ATR stop method. He introduces a new way to enter a trade, the "Impulse Method." (Appears to trade a lot so one might be better of with a discount broker using this one.) And he does expand his discussion on money management from the first book --which is good.

Am I glad I bought this book? Yes. I was like revisiting an old friend. Glad to see him again and know that they are still alive.

For those who have not yet read anything from Dr. Elder, I would suggest you get Trading for a Living and its workbook.

Ton of stuff there and will teach you how to trade using multiple time frames, -- something few authors discuss.

After that, use some of your profits and buy this book to thank Dr. Elder for writing the first one.

For purchase information and additional product details
Customer Review: 40 of 44



Customer Reviews


Come Into My Trading Room: A Complete Guide to Trading
Alexander Elder, Alexander Elder

Customer Review 39 - 41 of 44
39.Very Good, But Not as Good as "Trading for a Living"
(Santa Clara, CA United States) October 2, 2002 - 4.0/5 stars
This book covers all the basics of trading, from selecting which market(s) you are going to trade, to deciding on your trading timeframe, to picking entries and exits, and finally to money management and psychology... read full review
Current Review
40.Good, But Somewhat Disappointing
(Eleanor, WV United States) May 7, 2002 - 3.0/5 stars
Dr. Elders first book, "Trading for a Living" made a significant impact one me. I must have 10 "throw away" trading books for each of the 10-12 key books that have had most influence on me and that I keep close... read full review
41.Doesn't practice what he preaches
(London, UK) December 21, 2003 - 3.0/5 stars
I must agree with the previous reviewer (pkrider).Mr Elder spends a lot of time laying out the seemingly robust tenets of sound trading, only to blow his credibility in the last chapter, which reviews actual trades.To spend... read full review




Editorials

Sample 3 of 4

Come Into My Trading Room: A Complete Guide to Trading
Alexander Elder, Alexander Elder
 Book Description
The trading bible for the new millennium In A Complete Book of Trading, noted trader and author Dr. Alexander Elder returns to expand far beyond the three M's (Mind, Method, and Money) of his bestselling Trading for... read full editorial
 Book Info
Offers a complete introduction to trading essentials and an overview of trading psychology, both individual and mass psychology of the markets. Provides a step by step guide to risk control and money management.
 From the Inside Flap
How long will it take you to become a competent trader and how much will it cost? What markets should you trade and how much can you expect to make? What rules should you set, what methods should you use, how should... read full editorial





Top 10 Best Selling Money-Employment Book Categories


Top 10 List  |  Top 25 List  |  Similar Items in eBooks
Search [help]

List All Products  |  List Books  |  List eBooks
Contact